I wrote before how I was captivated by this Japanese boy singing a song that Josh Groban made famous, You Raise Me Up.
So anyway, I decided to look up more of his YouTube videos and was listening to this one called, Sen No Kaze ni Natte. Kawai Yuto is the young Japanese boy and he's singing at a Korean TV show. It looks something like America's Got Talent. So the judges are speaking in Korean but Yuto is singing in Japanese.
As I listened to the words, it suddenly struck me that the lyrics are awfully, awfully familiar. My Japanese is VERY faulty. Mom tells me not to speak Japanese if I'm in Japan. However, I recognized the first words as sounding like Do not cry at my grave. And then I'm hearing words like snow, then a star in the sky to watch over you, a bird, and wind in the sky...
It reminded me of the poem I'd heard a long time ago. I thought it was from the Civil War. My brain must be mixed up. Anyway, Just to prove you can find anything on the web, I looked online for the possible translation from Japanese to English.
Well... looking further I discovered it was not written during the Civil War. AI said it was attributed to Mary Elizabeth Frye (1905–2004). This is not true either.
When I looked it up on Wikipedia it said that Frye claimed she'd written it and said it was confirmed by Dear Abby. However,
Kansas native Clare Harner (1909–1977) first published "Immortality" in the December 1934 issue of poetry magazine The Gypsyand was reprinted in their February 1935 issue:
Clare Harner wrote it after the sad, sudden death of her brother.
When I looked further on YouTube, it turned out singer, Akikawa, Masafumi had written the Japanese version of the poem and made it into this beautiful song, "Sen no Kaze in Natte" which Yuto sang later.
All this just proves you can find out anything on the web, BUT you can't rely on just AI. You have to dig further on your own.
And to close, here are the original words to Clare Harner's beautiful poem:
Do not stand
By my grave, and weep.
I am not there,
I do not sleep—
I am the thousand winds that blow
I am the diamond glints in snow
I am the sunlight on ripened grain,
I am the gentle, autumn rain.
As you awake with morning's hush,
I am the swift, up-flinging rush
Of quiet birds in circling flight,
I am the day transcending night.
Do not stand
By my grave, and cry—
I am not there,
I did not die.
— Clare Harner, The Gypsy, December 1934
POSTSCRIPT:
I did more digging. I still had that Civil War thing on my mind so I looked up Ken Burns' Civil War series which is where I thought I'd heard this poem.
OK, it wasn't this poem by Clare Harner, but part of a letter written by Sullivan Ballou to his wife, Sarah that was read during the Ken Burns series. The letter was never mailed because he was killed the week after at the First Battle of Bull Run in July 21, 1861. It was found later after Sarah had already passed away.
"But, O Sarah! If the dead can come back to this earth and flit unseen around those they loved, I shall always be near you; in the gladdest days and in the darkest nights … always, always, and if there be a soft breeze upon your cheek, it shall be my breath, as the cool air fans your throbbing temple, it shall be my spirit passing by. Sarah do not mourn me dead; think I am gone and wait for thee, for we shall meet again …"
I love the poem. Ty for investigating its origins. I know this is true but I’m weeping for me in the loss of my Sister. I miss her so much. I’m not weeping for her but having a pity party for myself. Yesterday I was mad at her all day. The nasty weather here doesn’t help. I stuck inside and I hate that. Let the sun shine in Arkansas like it’s Hawaii 💚
I've found my attempts to use AI have shown the same thing. It gets a lot of things wrong. The one saving grace is by using an AI built into a search engine like Google, it provides the links from which it formulated the answer to it is fairly trivial at that point to go in and verify.
I love the poem but isn't your research interesting. I sometimes do a deep-dive about a subject like you did and find so many interesting facts along the way. The challenge can be to stay with your original search subject. LOL.
Researching in the days of the internet is interesting, isn't it? And AI just makes it worse (in my opinion). I usually preface remarks by saying "Well, I read it on the internet so it must be true" when my audience knows immediately that I am being sarcastic. The poem is so precious and meaningful. I have heard it read many times. Everytime it brings to mind someone I have lost. Today, my friend Denise.
You know... it made me tear up to just read that poem again and think of the 4 friends I lost in the last 3 years. I still forget that they're no longer here.
Our challenge is to live with all of this significance, especially at our age and yet to find childlike, joy and appreciation in every single day. Together we can Kay. Aloha!
Wow, Kay. That poem is what I truly believe - and perhaps that is why I do not cry when loved ones pass on. Thank you very much for sharing. I feel goosebumps.
Love the boy's voice and his take on it, so quiet and clear. I love the poem, too. It is quite often printed on the obiturary page in our paper, I guess because there is no attribution cost. It is hard not to love the boy sopranos, so ephemeral, so young the voices.
a nice read with such interesting perspectives, i have a living will, i will not have a grave, i want my ashes scattered in the ocean and in ocean county part. the hubs can keep a handful, if he so desired!! he knows what to do because of my living will!!
What a great research, Kay! AI is not always correct. Nearly 20 years ago when 千の風になって made a big hit in Japan, I heard one theory that the original was a poem left in a letter given to his parents by a young man who became a victim of IRA terrorist attack. This doesn’t seem to be correct. 新井万Arai Man, Akutagawa Prize-winning author, wrote Japanese lyrics based on "Do not stand at my grave and weep" and composed the music himself. Masashi Akikawa’s performance made it a major hit in Japan. Incidentally, my grandson is 悠人/Yuto, though he’s not a good singer like 結人/Yuto. Yoko
Wow! Thank you for your information, Yoko. My cousin once removed just told me this morning that she remembers that song being a hit in Japan too when she was in college. I'm sure your grandson is totemo kawai. :-)
I really LOVE hearing from you! However, if you sign in as ANONYMOUS, please don't forget to tell me who you are in the comment box by just writing your first name. We would all appreciate it if you kept your comment respectful and kind.
I’m using Comment Moderation for any post that is more than a day old because of aggravating SPAM. Therefore, if your comment does not go up on an older (more than a day old) post, it's because I need to OK it first. I'm sorry to have to do this, but again... sigh... it's the spam that's driving me crazy.
This is a very touching poem for me right now.
ReplyDeleteI love the poem. Ty for investigating its origins. I know this is true but I’m weeping for me in the loss of my Sister. I miss her so much. I’m not weeping for her but having a pity party for myself. Yesterday I was mad at her all day. The nasty weather here doesn’t help. I stuck inside and I hate that. Let the sun shine in Arkansas like it’s Hawaii 💚
ReplyDeleteGood researching. It is certainly a familiar poem to me.
ReplyDeleteI've found my attempts to use AI have shown the same thing. It gets a lot of things wrong. The one saving grace is by using an AI built into a search engine like Google, it provides the links from which it formulated the answer to it is fairly trivial at that point to go in and verify.
ReplyDeleteThat is a beautiful poem, often recited at funerals.
ReplyDeleteI've read that poem before. Thank you for searching out its history.
ReplyDeleteBeautiful
ReplyDeleteWhat a lovely poem. How different the gentle clear voice on that program compared to the strong "diva" voices we hear on American programing!
ReplyDeleteI love the poem but isn't your research interesting. I sometimes do a deep-dive about a subject like you did and find so many interesting facts along the way. The challenge can be to stay with your original search subject. LOL.
ReplyDeleteThat's such a beautiful and heartrending poem.
ReplyDeleteThat was an interesting trip through online research. It really is hard to know what to believe anymore.
ReplyDeleteResearching in the days of the internet is interesting, isn't it? And AI just makes it worse (in my opinion). I usually preface remarks by saying "Well, I read it on the internet so it must be true" when my audience knows immediately that I am being sarcastic.
ReplyDeleteThe poem is so precious and meaningful. I have heard it read many times. Everytime it brings to mind someone I have lost. Today, my friend Denise.
Lovely poem. Thanks for doing the research. It would be nice at a funeral service too. Or even printed on a memorial pamphlet. Linda in Kansas
ReplyDeleteYou know... it made me tear up to just read that poem again and think of the 4 friends I lost in the last 3 years. I still forget that they're no longer here.
DeleteOur challenge is to live with all of this significance, especially at our age and yet to find childlike, joy and appreciation in every single day. Together we can Kay. Aloha!
ReplyDeleteWow, Kay. That poem is what I truly believe - and perhaps that is why I do not cry when loved ones pass on. Thank you very much for sharing. I feel goosebumps.
ReplyDeleteLove the boy's voice and his take on it, so quiet and clear. I love the poem, too. It is quite often printed on the obiturary page in our paper, I guess because there is no attribution cost. It is hard not to love the boy sopranos, so ephemeral, so young the voices.
ReplyDeleteYou went down a rabbit hole but you taught the rest of us a lesson.
ReplyDeleteIt is a beautiful poem Kay and thank you so much for doing the research. Those young men have beautiful voices.
ReplyDeletea nice read with such interesting perspectives, i have a living will, i will not have a grave, i want my ashes scattered in the ocean and in ocean county part. the hubs can keep a handful, if he so desired!! he knows what to do because of my living will!!
ReplyDeleteI intend to be planted when I die, rather than cremated. It's available here in Washington State.
ReplyDeleteYou know I dearly love the research that you did on this. Thank you! Love the song in Japanese.Glad you got that here too.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great research, Kay! AI is not always correct. Nearly 20 years ago when 千の風になって made a big hit in Japan, I heard one theory that the original was a poem left in a letter given to his parents by a young man who became a victim of IRA terrorist attack. This doesn’t seem to be correct.
ReplyDelete新井万Arai Man, Akutagawa Prize-winning author, wrote Japanese lyrics based on "Do not stand at my grave and weep" and composed the music himself. Masashi Akikawa’s performance made it a major hit in Japan.
Incidentally, my grandson is 悠人/Yuto, though he’s not a good singer like 結人/Yuto.
Yoko
Wow! Thank you for your information, Yoko. My cousin once removed just told me this morning that she remembers that song being a hit in Japan too when she was in college. I'm sure your grandson is totemo kawai. :-)
Delete